Part 82
Posted: Sun Jul 09, 2017 9:15 pm
We're nearing the end here, though this is NOT the last part. It's a long epilogue.
There WILL be a third story in this series, though I've been struggling with some major writer's block lately, so I don't know how soon I will be posting it.
Music suggestion is the beautiful (and sad) "She Has No Time" by Keane, which I listened to on repeat for a certain part of this fic. You an listen to it here when you see
if you'd like.
Part 82
Epilogue
No one ever thought I’d get anywhere in life. But I did. I got here. When I went to college, my life went somewhere.
Suck on that, Mr. Frost.
I never have quite understood why my college picked Pistol Pete as a mascot, though, even though I’ve grown to appreciate it. Why not just use a generic cowboy instead? Why use a guy who left a trail of bodies in his wake? He’s not a good guy.
But he’s a legend, so they say. The ultimate brave cowboy who never backs down, never gives up, never quits fighting for what he wants.
I wonder what he wanted. Probably that girl who gave him the cross, right? The cross that saved his life in a shootout. You never know what’s gonna save you. Just like you never know what might destroy you.
But I don’t think old Pete ever really had that girl. She died before he could thank her.
That doesn’t seem fair.
Would he have even bothered to thank her, though? Not likely, if you ask me. He wasn’t a hero. Cowboys aren’t heroes, despite what the movies might want you to believe. But they don’t have to be villains, either. Being dangerous isn’t the same thing as being bad.
I know Pistol Pete wasn’t a hero; and I know he wasn’t a villain.
I don’t know which one I am. But I know which one I wanna be.
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
(
)
The wait was agonizing. It seemed endless, and the longer it dragged on, the more Michael wondered what the hell they were waiting for. Didn’t these tests only take a couple of minutes? Sarah had been out of that bathroom for ten minutes now, but she’d just sat down on the couch and fallen silent. She wasn’t making any move to get up and go back in. It was like she was catatonic or something, and he, on the flipside, couldn’t sit still. He paced back and forth, trying to keep his breathing steady, even though that got harder and harder with each minute that dragged by.
Finally, though, he just couldn’t take it anymore, and he had to say something. “I think . . . we can go check it now.” Hint, hint.
She shook her head stubbornly. “No, I’m not ready for that.”
Not ready? What, did she prefer the torture of this? “Well . . . I am,” he said, hoping that would be enough for her to get ready.
“That doesn’t matter to me, Michael,” she snapped.
“Hey, I might not be the one who’s pregnant, but this affects me, too,” he reminded her, his voice rising in volume despite his desire to stay calm for her. “I just wanna know. You took the test. Let’s go see what it says.”
There was this sweeping look of hurt in her eyes when he said that, like she hated him for being insensitive or something. He couldn’t bear to see her look that way, not under normal circumstances, and definitely not now. So he shut himself up and relented to more waiting.
Instead of pacing, he took a seat next to her on the couch, careful not to sit too close. His eyes swept over her, studying her, taking in the sight of that long, dark hair and those thick eyelashes for the first time in weeks. He’d almost forgotten how small she was compared to him, but . . . maybe she wouldn’t be small much longer.
He glanced at her stomach, thinking that it didn’t . . . it didn’t look pregnant.
“Did you ever really love me?” she asked him suddenly, her voice a mere whisper, a fraction of what it usually was. “Or was I always just the girl you dated because you couldn’t have Maria?”
He hated that he’d given her reason to doubt their relationship, everything they’d shared. “No, I loved you,” he assured her. Those two and a half years with her had been some of the best of his life. “A lot.”
That didn’t seem to be any consolation at all. If anything, she looked even more hurt knowing that it had been real. “I remember our first night here in this place,” she recalled, glancing over her shoulder at the bed that used to be their bed. “I couldn’t fall asleep, and when I did, I had a nightmare.” She inhaled shakily, her eyes shimmering with tears that were right on the edge. “When I woke up, I was trembling, and you just put your arms around me and held me, and you said, ‘Don’t worry. Everything’s gonna be alright.’” She tried to smile, but it was more of a sad grimace than anything else.
He knew he couldn’t do that anymore, but he could still try to be reassuring. “It is gonna be alright,” he said, not sure what gave him the authority to make such a promise. He just felt like, if he didn’t, she’d break apart into a million pieces right before his eyes.
“It just doesn’t sound as convincing anymore.” She hung her head, staring down at her lap blankly, and he swore he’d never seen her look more lost.
“Sarah, I’m right here,” he told her. “You’re not doin’ this alone.”
“I am alone, though,” she insisted, seeing right through the thin veil of comfort in his words. “It wasn’t supposed to happen this way. We were supposed to be together.”
“We don’t even know if . . .” He looked over helplessly at the bathroom door. It was open just a bit, the light from inside peeking through. They didn’t even know if anything was happening. Maybe it was all just a false alarm. A scare.
She sighed heavily and wrapped both arms around her stomach, and he wasn’t sure whether it was because she nervous or because she was envisioning a baby in there. “You can go look now,” she mumbled.
Great, so he had her permission. Although . . . suddenly, he didn’t feel so eager to find out anymore. “You don’t want to?” he asked. “We could do it together.”
She shook her head fearfully. “I can’t.”
He let out a heavy breath, knowing that meant he had to. As petrified as he was feeling, he had to hold it together and go find out for her. For them. Find out if they were having a baby. Find out if he was going to be a dad.
“Okay.” He reached over and put his hand on her leg, giving it a gentle squeeze, and much to his surprise, she let him.
He lumbered over to the bathroom, feeling like he was going in slow motion, just trying to concentrate on putting one foot in front of the other. It was all so familiar that he couldn’t help but flash back to the last time he’d done this. He’d been an eighteen year old boy then, and Maria had been the girl who couldn’t bear to look. But as naïve and as clueless as he’d been back then . . . he’d been something else, too: hopeful. He hadn’t dreaded the thought of seeing a positive result on that test, and now he did. Three years later, when his life actually was somewhat on track and he’d learned to be responsible . . . this was when the dread kicked in.
He swiped the testing strip off the sink and clasped his hand over the result window, terrified. It wasn’t Sarah’s fault that this was happening, and it wasn’t like he didn’t want it. He wanted kids. Just . . .
He stood in the doorway, gulping hard, and slowly peeled his hand back from the results window, barely brave enough to even look down at it. His eyes flittered all around it but never quite focused on it until . . .
Until he couldn’t not. He caught sight of one pink line. And then another. And he knew what that meant.
Pregnant.
It was positive, and positive was supposed to be a good thing.
He looked at Sarah, who couldn’t seem to look at him. Her tear-filled eyes bore straight ahead at the wall.
In an instant, it was like the whole world fell away, and he couldn’t even feel the floor under his feet or the test in his hand. His arms and legs felt numb, and his heart dropped into his stomach. He peered down at the test again to make sure he was seeing it right.
He was.
His throat felt dry, and no words came out. But apparently they weren’t necessary. Sarah sat stiff as a board on the couch, thoroughly saturated in stress and anxiety, and she didn’t even look over at him. But whether it was just a knowing feeling she had or a silence that said it all, she seemed to understand.
Pregnant.
She pressed her lips together tightly as they trembled, but eventually she just squeezed her eyes shut and started to cry. Her whole body crumpled in on itself, and her shoulders shook as the sobs poured out of her.
As if all the air had gone out of his lungs, he slumped against the doorframe, struggling to stay upright. He wanted to cry, just like Sarah was, but he didn’t. He thought of Maria, and then he thought of Dylan . . . and then he tried to think of something to say. As if the lump in his throat would allow him to say anything. Something supportive, maybe, something reassuring. Something to make Sarah feel like the world wasn’t ending, even though it seemed like it was.
But he had no idea what to say.
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
Max roamed through his house, alarmed by the silence. Without Dylan around, there was just no noise, no laughter. Nothing. It was crazy to think that all that shouting he and Maria had done could be reduced to this. And this . . . this was what Maria wanted for him. She wanted him to end up alone. Hell, her first instinct following their confrontation was to take Dylan and high-tail it out of there. Clearly she’d never be willing to share him. She thought she knew what was best for him; she thought she was the better parent.
She had No. Fucking. Clue.
He went out on his porch and whipped out his phone, dialing a number he hadn’t bothered with in years, one he didn’t even have programmed into his phone anymore but still knew by heart.
Three rings in, a gruff voice answered, “Hello?”
He must not have recognized my number, Max thought, swallowing his pride. “Hi, Dad.”
His father didn’t say anything for a moment, probably shocked as hell. They hadn’t spoken since he’d gotten kicked out of college his sophomore year. Finally, though, he said, “Well, hello, son. It’s been a while.”
“A long while,” Max agreed. Personally, he would have been content to draw it out a little longer, but circumstances had changed. Things were coming to a head, and he needed a powerful ally in his corner. “I hope you don’t mind this isn’t a social call. I need a favor.”
“Of course you do,” his dad grumbled. “What do you need?”
Max looked down the hall at the open door to Dylan’s empty bedroom, fear surrounding what was left of his heart. “I need a lawyer.”
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
Instead of being the one who couldn’t sit still, Michael now could barely move. He sat on the couch with one leg up on the cushions, the other extended over to the coffee table while Sarah paced all around the living room, rattling off question after question, not one of which he had an answer for. She’d stopped crying, but now . . . she was just worked up.
“What’re we gonna do, Michael?” she fretted. “I mean, this is, like, the worst thing that could happen.”
You have no idea, he thought. This wasn’t what was supposed to have happened today. “We’ll figure it out,” he said, struggling to keep coming up with assuring things to say to her. The more it sunk in that they’d created a child together, the more overwhelmed he felt.
“But we’re not even together,” she reminded him. “How are we gonna figure this out if we’re not even . . .” She trailed off and gasped, obviously on the verge of another sobbing breakdown. “God, this is just . . . it isn’t fair. I don’t even know why . . . I mean, I was on the pill. I always took it.”
“Nothin’ works a hundred percent of the time,” he mumbled, wishing he could go back in time and just put on a fucking condom. Then, chances were, this whole crisis could have been avoided. But no, he had to be a fucking moron.
“But it should’ve worked,” she protested, shaking her head frustratedly. “We shouldn’t . . . we shouldn’t be having a baby. We’re not ready for that.”
You’re not a kid anymore, Michael reminded himself. You’re an adult. You can handle this.
“Would you say something?” she demanded shrilly.
He rubbed his forehead, scraping the bottom of the reassurance barrel when he reused the same line he’d already said a dozen times that day. “It’s gonna be alright.”
“Not that.”
“Why not?” It didn’t hurt to put a little positive energy out there, did it? Not that he was feeling all that positive.
“You don’t know if it’s gonna be alright,” she bit out. “And even if you did, I wouldn’t believe you.”
Because you don’t trust me, he recognized. And why would she? Shit. He’d fathered a child with a girl who didn’t trust him anymore. “Look, this whole thing . . .” He stood up, muscles aching like he’d aged ten years in just one day. “It caught me off guard, alright?”
“Oh, and what, I was so prepared for it?”
“No, I didn’t . . .” He understood why she’d snap at him right now, but it was really hard for him to be the calm one about all of this. “I’m tryin’ my best here.”
Her jaw shook as she tilted her head back to hold the tears in. “This can’t be happening,” she choked out. “I can’t be pregnant. I just . . . god, I was gonna go home this summer and everything. And I was gonna transfer.”
The hairs on the back of his neck stood up in alarm. “To Las Cruces?”
“Yeah, but now what do I do?”
You don’t go, he thought, but he didn’t want to seem like he was giving her an order. “We don’t have to think about that right now,” he said, but hell, he’d be thinking about it. Maybe these weren’t the ideal circumstances to be having a kid, but he did not want to be an absentee parent, just a name in a Christmas card.
“Michael, we have to think about these things,” she insisted. Every time she said we, her voice wavered a bit, like she was struggling to think of them that way.
“I can’t do this right now,” he breathed out suddenly.
“And you think I can?”
It was too much, too much craziness to take in and deal with at once. Sarah needed him and Maria needed him, and he just felt like he didn’t know what to do for either one of them. So he was failing them both. “I’ve got too much goin’ on. I—I can’t—there’s too much! I can’t even--”
“Why don’t you just say it, Michael?” she cut in.
“Say what?”
She rubbed her stomach sadly, sniffing back tears. “You don’t want this. You don’t want this baby.”
No, that wasn’t it. His dad hadn’t wanted him, and he refused to be anything like that. “Yeah, I do,” he insisted, knowing that this could be the greatest thing that ever happened to him in the long run. It just didn’t feel like that now.
“Not with me,” she cried, fresh tears falling down her face. “You want it with Maria!”
His breath caught in his throat, and he couldn’t deny it. He didn’t want to lie to her again, especially not when she so clearly already knew the truth.
When his phone rang, he wanted to smash it. Even if it was Maria calling. Especially if it was her.
“Is that her?” Sarah asked.
He picked up his phone, surprised to see that it wasn’t. “No, it’s Isabel.”
“Oh, is she your girlfriend now, too?” Sarah snorted.
He ignored that, knowing he probably deserved it. Damn, he couldn’t for the life of him come up with a reason for why she’d be calling, but hell, she’d probably just keep calling back if he didn’t answer. So he did, but he didn’t bother trying to be polite. “What?”
She didn’t say anything for a few seconds, and when she did, all it was was a high-pitched, pathetic-sounding, “Michael?”
“Now’s not a really a good time,” he told her.
“No, please, don’t hang up,” she begged, “please!”
He rolled his eyes in annoyance and turned his back towards Sarah. “What do you want?”
She breathed in sharply and whimpered, “I’m scared.”
“What’re you talkin’ about?” He was losing patience fast.
“I’m really scared, Michael.”
“Then call your boyfriend,” he suggested.
“No, I can’t call him! I hate him!” she bleated.
Oh, fuck, he thought, wishing he’d never taken this call. He was so not the right person to listen to her relationship troubles, especially not given his own current problem. “I can’t deal with this right now,” he said, about to end the call.
“No, Michael, you don’t understand!” she practically screamed.
“I’m hanging up.”
“I feel like killing myself!”
His mouth dropped open in shocked silence, and at first, he thought maybe he’d heard her wrong. But then he remembered the pill incident earlier this year, and something told him this wasn’t just a ploy for attention this time. She meant that.
“W-what?” he sputtered, not sure how to deal with this. “Isabel, what do you mean you . . .”
She just started crying. Or kept crying, perhaps.
Shit, this wasn’t good. He dug his hand through his hair, trying to think of what to do. “Okay, where are you?” he asked, figuring the most logical thing was just to get to her. Then at least he could try to talk her down face to face.
“At my house,” she replied. “Alone.”
Alone. That wasn’t good. She couldn’t be alone right now. He’d read enough psychology reports and had enough common sense to know that much. “Okay, just . . . just wait there, alright?” he instructed her. “I’ll come get you.”
No response.
“Isabel.” He just needed her to hang in there for ten minutes.
“I’ll wait,” she said.
“Okay, I’m on my way.” He ended the call, pocketed his phone, and hurried towards the bed to find his keys.
“What’s going on?” Sarah questioned.
“I gotta go.” Dammit, where the hell had he put those keys? Not on the nightstand, not in the drawer.
“What? Michael!” she yelped.
He checked under his pillow, and for some reason, there they were. “I’ll be back,” he promised, brushing past her on his way to the door.
“No, you can’t just leave me!” she cried, scurrying after him. “We have to deal with this.”
He knew they did, and they would. Just not right now. “I’m sorry,” he said, hoping she still knew him well enough to know that he wouldn’t just take off without a good reason. “I have to go.”
That downcast, confused look on her face made it so hard to walk out the door. But he did it anyway.
TBC . . .
-April
There WILL be a third story in this series, though I've been struggling with some major writer's block lately, so I don't know how soon I will be posting it.
Music suggestion is the beautiful (and sad) "She Has No Time" by Keane, which I listened to on repeat for a certain part of this fic. You an listen to it here when you see

Part 82
Epilogue
No one ever thought I’d get anywhere in life. But I did. I got here. When I went to college, my life went somewhere.
Suck on that, Mr. Frost.
I never have quite understood why my college picked Pistol Pete as a mascot, though, even though I’ve grown to appreciate it. Why not just use a generic cowboy instead? Why use a guy who left a trail of bodies in his wake? He’s not a good guy.
But he’s a legend, so they say. The ultimate brave cowboy who never backs down, never gives up, never quits fighting for what he wants.
I wonder what he wanted. Probably that girl who gave him the cross, right? The cross that saved his life in a shootout. You never know what’s gonna save you. Just like you never know what might destroy you.
But I don’t think old Pete ever really had that girl. She died before he could thank her.
That doesn’t seem fair.
Would he have even bothered to thank her, though? Not likely, if you ask me. He wasn’t a hero. Cowboys aren’t heroes, despite what the movies might want you to believe. But they don’t have to be villains, either. Being dangerous isn’t the same thing as being bad.
I know Pistol Pete wasn’t a hero; and I know he wasn’t a villain.
I don’t know which one I am. But I know which one I wanna be.
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
(

The wait was agonizing. It seemed endless, and the longer it dragged on, the more Michael wondered what the hell they were waiting for. Didn’t these tests only take a couple of minutes? Sarah had been out of that bathroom for ten minutes now, but she’d just sat down on the couch and fallen silent. She wasn’t making any move to get up and go back in. It was like she was catatonic or something, and he, on the flipside, couldn’t sit still. He paced back and forth, trying to keep his breathing steady, even though that got harder and harder with each minute that dragged by.
Finally, though, he just couldn’t take it anymore, and he had to say something. “I think . . . we can go check it now.” Hint, hint.
She shook her head stubbornly. “No, I’m not ready for that.”
Not ready? What, did she prefer the torture of this? “Well . . . I am,” he said, hoping that would be enough for her to get ready.
“That doesn’t matter to me, Michael,” she snapped.
“Hey, I might not be the one who’s pregnant, but this affects me, too,” he reminded her, his voice rising in volume despite his desire to stay calm for her. “I just wanna know. You took the test. Let’s go see what it says.”
There was this sweeping look of hurt in her eyes when he said that, like she hated him for being insensitive or something. He couldn’t bear to see her look that way, not under normal circumstances, and definitely not now. So he shut himself up and relented to more waiting.
Instead of pacing, he took a seat next to her on the couch, careful not to sit too close. His eyes swept over her, studying her, taking in the sight of that long, dark hair and those thick eyelashes for the first time in weeks. He’d almost forgotten how small she was compared to him, but . . . maybe she wouldn’t be small much longer.
He glanced at her stomach, thinking that it didn’t . . . it didn’t look pregnant.
“Did you ever really love me?” she asked him suddenly, her voice a mere whisper, a fraction of what it usually was. “Or was I always just the girl you dated because you couldn’t have Maria?”
He hated that he’d given her reason to doubt their relationship, everything they’d shared. “No, I loved you,” he assured her. Those two and a half years with her had been some of the best of his life. “A lot.”
That didn’t seem to be any consolation at all. If anything, she looked even more hurt knowing that it had been real. “I remember our first night here in this place,” she recalled, glancing over her shoulder at the bed that used to be their bed. “I couldn’t fall asleep, and when I did, I had a nightmare.” She inhaled shakily, her eyes shimmering with tears that were right on the edge. “When I woke up, I was trembling, and you just put your arms around me and held me, and you said, ‘Don’t worry. Everything’s gonna be alright.’” She tried to smile, but it was more of a sad grimace than anything else.
He knew he couldn’t do that anymore, but he could still try to be reassuring. “It is gonna be alright,” he said, not sure what gave him the authority to make such a promise. He just felt like, if he didn’t, she’d break apart into a million pieces right before his eyes.
“It just doesn’t sound as convincing anymore.” She hung her head, staring down at her lap blankly, and he swore he’d never seen her look more lost.
“Sarah, I’m right here,” he told her. “You’re not doin’ this alone.”
“I am alone, though,” she insisted, seeing right through the thin veil of comfort in his words. “It wasn’t supposed to happen this way. We were supposed to be together.”
“We don’t even know if . . .” He looked over helplessly at the bathroom door. It was open just a bit, the light from inside peeking through. They didn’t even know if anything was happening. Maybe it was all just a false alarm. A scare.
She sighed heavily and wrapped both arms around her stomach, and he wasn’t sure whether it was because she nervous or because she was envisioning a baby in there. “You can go look now,” she mumbled.
Great, so he had her permission. Although . . . suddenly, he didn’t feel so eager to find out anymore. “You don’t want to?” he asked. “We could do it together.”
She shook her head fearfully. “I can’t.”
He let out a heavy breath, knowing that meant he had to. As petrified as he was feeling, he had to hold it together and go find out for her. For them. Find out if they were having a baby. Find out if he was going to be a dad.
“Okay.” He reached over and put his hand on her leg, giving it a gentle squeeze, and much to his surprise, she let him.
He lumbered over to the bathroom, feeling like he was going in slow motion, just trying to concentrate on putting one foot in front of the other. It was all so familiar that he couldn’t help but flash back to the last time he’d done this. He’d been an eighteen year old boy then, and Maria had been the girl who couldn’t bear to look. But as naïve and as clueless as he’d been back then . . . he’d been something else, too: hopeful. He hadn’t dreaded the thought of seeing a positive result on that test, and now he did. Three years later, when his life actually was somewhat on track and he’d learned to be responsible . . . this was when the dread kicked in.
He swiped the testing strip off the sink and clasped his hand over the result window, terrified. It wasn’t Sarah’s fault that this was happening, and it wasn’t like he didn’t want it. He wanted kids. Just . . .
He stood in the doorway, gulping hard, and slowly peeled his hand back from the results window, barely brave enough to even look down at it. His eyes flittered all around it but never quite focused on it until . . .
Until he couldn’t not. He caught sight of one pink line. And then another. And he knew what that meant.
Pregnant.
It was positive, and positive was supposed to be a good thing.
He looked at Sarah, who couldn’t seem to look at him. Her tear-filled eyes bore straight ahead at the wall.
In an instant, it was like the whole world fell away, and he couldn’t even feel the floor under his feet or the test in his hand. His arms and legs felt numb, and his heart dropped into his stomach. He peered down at the test again to make sure he was seeing it right.
He was.
His throat felt dry, and no words came out. But apparently they weren’t necessary. Sarah sat stiff as a board on the couch, thoroughly saturated in stress and anxiety, and she didn’t even look over at him. But whether it was just a knowing feeling she had or a silence that said it all, she seemed to understand.
Pregnant.
She pressed her lips together tightly as they trembled, but eventually she just squeezed her eyes shut and started to cry. Her whole body crumpled in on itself, and her shoulders shook as the sobs poured out of her.
As if all the air had gone out of his lungs, he slumped against the doorframe, struggling to stay upright. He wanted to cry, just like Sarah was, but he didn’t. He thought of Maria, and then he thought of Dylan . . . and then he tried to think of something to say. As if the lump in his throat would allow him to say anything. Something supportive, maybe, something reassuring. Something to make Sarah feel like the world wasn’t ending, even though it seemed like it was.
But he had no idea what to say.
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
Max roamed through his house, alarmed by the silence. Without Dylan around, there was just no noise, no laughter. Nothing. It was crazy to think that all that shouting he and Maria had done could be reduced to this. And this . . . this was what Maria wanted for him. She wanted him to end up alone. Hell, her first instinct following their confrontation was to take Dylan and high-tail it out of there. Clearly she’d never be willing to share him. She thought she knew what was best for him; she thought she was the better parent.
She had No. Fucking. Clue.
He went out on his porch and whipped out his phone, dialing a number he hadn’t bothered with in years, one he didn’t even have programmed into his phone anymore but still knew by heart.
Three rings in, a gruff voice answered, “Hello?”
He must not have recognized my number, Max thought, swallowing his pride. “Hi, Dad.”
His father didn’t say anything for a moment, probably shocked as hell. They hadn’t spoken since he’d gotten kicked out of college his sophomore year. Finally, though, he said, “Well, hello, son. It’s been a while.”
“A long while,” Max agreed. Personally, he would have been content to draw it out a little longer, but circumstances had changed. Things were coming to a head, and he needed a powerful ally in his corner. “I hope you don’t mind this isn’t a social call. I need a favor.”
“Of course you do,” his dad grumbled. “What do you need?”
Max looked down the hall at the open door to Dylan’s empty bedroom, fear surrounding what was left of his heart. “I need a lawyer.”
~*~*~*~*~*~*~
Instead of being the one who couldn’t sit still, Michael now could barely move. He sat on the couch with one leg up on the cushions, the other extended over to the coffee table while Sarah paced all around the living room, rattling off question after question, not one of which he had an answer for. She’d stopped crying, but now . . . she was just worked up.
“What’re we gonna do, Michael?” she fretted. “I mean, this is, like, the worst thing that could happen.”
You have no idea, he thought. This wasn’t what was supposed to have happened today. “We’ll figure it out,” he said, struggling to keep coming up with assuring things to say to her. The more it sunk in that they’d created a child together, the more overwhelmed he felt.
“But we’re not even together,” she reminded him. “How are we gonna figure this out if we’re not even . . .” She trailed off and gasped, obviously on the verge of another sobbing breakdown. “God, this is just . . . it isn’t fair. I don’t even know why . . . I mean, I was on the pill. I always took it.”
“Nothin’ works a hundred percent of the time,” he mumbled, wishing he could go back in time and just put on a fucking condom. Then, chances were, this whole crisis could have been avoided. But no, he had to be a fucking moron.
“But it should’ve worked,” she protested, shaking her head frustratedly. “We shouldn’t . . . we shouldn’t be having a baby. We’re not ready for that.”
You’re not a kid anymore, Michael reminded himself. You’re an adult. You can handle this.
“Would you say something?” she demanded shrilly.
He rubbed his forehead, scraping the bottom of the reassurance barrel when he reused the same line he’d already said a dozen times that day. “It’s gonna be alright.”
“Not that.”
“Why not?” It didn’t hurt to put a little positive energy out there, did it? Not that he was feeling all that positive.
“You don’t know if it’s gonna be alright,” she bit out. “And even if you did, I wouldn’t believe you.”
Because you don’t trust me, he recognized. And why would she? Shit. He’d fathered a child with a girl who didn’t trust him anymore. “Look, this whole thing . . .” He stood up, muscles aching like he’d aged ten years in just one day. “It caught me off guard, alright?”
“Oh, and what, I was so prepared for it?”
“No, I didn’t . . .” He understood why she’d snap at him right now, but it was really hard for him to be the calm one about all of this. “I’m tryin’ my best here.”
Her jaw shook as she tilted her head back to hold the tears in. “This can’t be happening,” she choked out. “I can’t be pregnant. I just . . . god, I was gonna go home this summer and everything. And I was gonna transfer.”
The hairs on the back of his neck stood up in alarm. “To Las Cruces?”
“Yeah, but now what do I do?”
You don’t go, he thought, but he didn’t want to seem like he was giving her an order. “We don’t have to think about that right now,” he said, but hell, he’d be thinking about it. Maybe these weren’t the ideal circumstances to be having a kid, but he did not want to be an absentee parent, just a name in a Christmas card.
“Michael, we have to think about these things,” she insisted. Every time she said we, her voice wavered a bit, like she was struggling to think of them that way.
“I can’t do this right now,” he breathed out suddenly.
“And you think I can?”
It was too much, too much craziness to take in and deal with at once. Sarah needed him and Maria needed him, and he just felt like he didn’t know what to do for either one of them. So he was failing them both. “I’ve got too much goin’ on. I—I can’t—there’s too much! I can’t even--”
“Why don’t you just say it, Michael?” she cut in.
“Say what?”
She rubbed her stomach sadly, sniffing back tears. “You don’t want this. You don’t want this baby.”
No, that wasn’t it. His dad hadn’t wanted him, and he refused to be anything like that. “Yeah, I do,” he insisted, knowing that this could be the greatest thing that ever happened to him in the long run. It just didn’t feel like that now.
“Not with me,” she cried, fresh tears falling down her face. “You want it with Maria!”
His breath caught in his throat, and he couldn’t deny it. He didn’t want to lie to her again, especially not when she so clearly already knew the truth.
When his phone rang, he wanted to smash it. Even if it was Maria calling. Especially if it was her.
“Is that her?” Sarah asked.
He picked up his phone, surprised to see that it wasn’t. “No, it’s Isabel.”
“Oh, is she your girlfriend now, too?” Sarah snorted.
He ignored that, knowing he probably deserved it. Damn, he couldn’t for the life of him come up with a reason for why she’d be calling, but hell, she’d probably just keep calling back if he didn’t answer. So he did, but he didn’t bother trying to be polite. “What?”
She didn’t say anything for a few seconds, and when she did, all it was was a high-pitched, pathetic-sounding, “Michael?”
“Now’s not a really a good time,” he told her.
“No, please, don’t hang up,” she begged, “please!”
He rolled his eyes in annoyance and turned his back towards Sarah. “What do you want?”
She breathed in sharply and whimpered, “I’m scared.”
“What’re you talkin’ about?” He was losing patience fast.
“I’m really scared, Michael.”
“Then call your boyfriend,” he suggested.
“No, I can’t call him! I hate him!” she bleated.
Oh, fuck, he thought, wishing he’d never taken this call. He was so not the right person to listen to her relationship troubles, especially not given his own current problem. “I can’t deal with this right now,” he said, about to end the call.
“No, Michael, you don’t understand!” she practically screamed.
“I’m hanging up.”
“I feel like killing myself!”
His mouth dropped open in shocked silence, and at first, he thought maybe he’d heard her wrong. But then he remembered the pill incident earlier this year, and something told him this wasn’t just a ploy for attention this time. She meant that.
“W-what?” he sputtered, not sure how to deal with this. “Isabel, what do you mean you . . .”
She just started crying. Or kept crying, perhaps.
Shit, this wasn’t good. He dug his hand through his hair, trying to think of what to do. “Okay, where are you?” he asked, figuring the most logical thing was just to get to her. Then at least he could try to talk her down face to face.
“At my house,” she replied. “Alone.”
Alone. That wasn’t good. She couldn’t be alone right now. He’d read enough psychology reports and had enough common sense to know that much. “Okay, just . . . just wait there, alright?” he instructed her. “I’ll come get you.”
No response.
“Isabel.” He just needed her to hang in there for ten minutes.
“I’ll wait,” she said.
“Okay, I’m on my way.” He ended the call, pocketed his phone, and hurried towards the bed to find his keys.
“What’s going on?” Sarah questioned.
“I gotta go.” Dammit, where the hell had he put those keys? Not on the nightstand, not in the drawer.
“What? Michael!” she yelped.
He checked under his pillow, and for some reason, there they were. “I’ll be back,” he promised, brushing past her on his way to the door.
“No, you can’t just leave me!” she cried, scurrying after him. “We have to deal with this.”
He knew they did, and they would. Just not right now. “I’m sorry,” he said, hoping she still knew him well enough to know that he wouldn’t just take off without a good reason. “I have to go.”
That downcast, confused look on her face made it so hard to walk out the door. But he did it anyway.
TBC . . .
-April